Comparison of Marek's Disease Virus Challenge Strains and Bird Types for Vaccine Licensing.

Marek's disease virus (MDV) is an important poultry pathogen that is controlled through widespread vaccination with avirulent and attenuated strains. However, continued evolution of field viruses to higher virulence has required ongoing improvement of available vaccine strains, and these vaccine strains offer an attractive platform for designing recombinant vector vaccines with cross-protection against MDV and additional pathogens. Recent reports of failures in vaccine licensing trials of positive controls to reach appropriately high levels of Marek's disease incidence prompted us to evaluate possible combinations of outbred specific-pathogen-free layer lines and alternative virulent challenge strains that could provide more consistent models for serotype 3 vectored vaccine development. Choice of layer line and virulent MDV challenge strain each contributed to the ability of a challenge model to reach 80% virulence in unvaccinated positive control groups in the majority of trials, without overwhelming serotype 3 vectored vaccine protection in vaccinated groups. Conversely, reducing challenge virus dose by a factor of four, or vaccine dose by half, had no consistent effect across these models. Although MDV strain 617A had the most potential as an alternative to strains that are currently approved for licensing trials, no combination of layer line and challenge virus consistently met the goals for a successful challenge model in all study replicates, indicating that high variability is an inherent difficulty in MDV challenge studies, at least when outbred birds are used.

Artículo regular­Comparación de las cepas de desafío del virus de la enfermedad de Marek y los tipos de aves para la obtención de licencias de vacunas. El virus de la enfermedad de Marek (MDV) es un patógeno importante en la avicultura que se controla mediante la vacunación generalizada con cepas avirulentas y atenuadas. Sin embargo, la evolución continua de los virus de campo hacia una mayor virulencia ha requerido una mejora continua de las cepas vacunales disponibles y estas cepas vacunales ofrecen una plataforma atractiva para diseñar vacunas con vectores recombinantes que induzcan protección cruzada contra el virus de la enfermedad de Marek y patógenos adicionales. Los reportes recientes de fallas en los controles positivos para alcanzar niveles apropiadamente altos de incidencia de la enfermedad de Marek en los ensayos para obtener la licencia de vacunas llevaron a evaluar posibles combinaciones de líneas de postura híbridas libres de patógenos específicos y cepas de desafío virulentas alternativas que podrían proporcionar modelos más consistentes para el desarrollo de vacunas con vectores de serotipo 3. Tanto la elección de la línea de postura como de la cepa de desafío virulenta de Marek contribuyeron a obtener un modelo de desafío con capacidad para alcanzar el 80% de virulencia en grupos controles positivo no vacunados en la mayoría de los ensayos, sin una protección abrumadora de la vacuna con vector de serotipo 3 en los grupos vacunados. Por el contrario, la reducción de la dosis del virus de desafío en un factor de cuatro, o la dosis de vacuna a la mitad, no tuvieron un efecto constante en estos modelos. Aunque la cepa 617A de Marek mostró el mayor potencial como alternativa a las cepas que actualmente están aprobadas para ensayos de licenciar vacunas, ninguna combinación de línea de postura y virus de desafío cumplió consistentemente los objetivos de un modelo de desafío exitoso en todas las réplicas del estudio, lo que indica que la alta variabilidad es una dificultad inherente en los estudios de desafío para la enfermedad de Marek, al menos cuando se utilizan aves híbridas.

Transcriptional Analyses of Innate and Acquired Immune Patterning Elicited by Marek's Disease Virus Vaccine Strains: Turkey Herpesvirus (HVT), Marek's Disease Virus 2 (strain SB1), and Bivalent Vaccines (HVT/SB1 and HVT-LT/SB1).

Marek's disease (MD) is a complex pathology of chickens caused by MD virus (MDV) 1 and is observed as paralysis, immune suppression, neurologic signs, and the rapid formation of T-cell lymphomas. The incidence of MD in commercial broilers is largely controlled via vaccination, either in ovo or at hatch with live attenuated vaccines, i.e., turkey herpesvirus (HVT) or a bivalent combination of HVT with the MDV 2 strain (SB1). To further extend the protection conferred by bivalent HVT/SB-1, recombinant HVTs encoding transgenes of other avian viruses have similarly been used for in ovo administration. Despite decades of use, the specific mechanisms associated with vaccine-induced protection remain obscure. Additionally, the mechanistic basis for vaccine synergism conferred by bivalent HVT/SB-1, compared with HVT or SB-1 administered alone, is largely unknown. In the present study, we report on temporal changes in innate and acquired immune-patterning gene expression by using ex vivo splenocyte infection and in ovo vaccination models. We report that in the ex vivo splenocyte infection model, by 72 hr postinfection, vaccines induced IFN and IFN-stimulated gene expression, with lesser proinflammatory cytokine induction. For several genes (TLR3, IFN-γ, OASL, Mx1, NOS2A, and IL-1ß), the effects on gene expression were additive for HVT, SB1, and HVT/SB1 infection. We observed similar patterns of induction in in ovo-vaccinated commercial broiler embryos and chicks with HVT/SB-1 or recombinant HVT-based bivalent combination (HVT-LT/SB-1). Furthermore, HVT/SB-1 or HVT-LT/SB-1 in ovo vaccination appeared to hasten immune maturation, with expression patterns suggesting accelerated migration of T and natural killer cells into the spleen. Finally, HVT/SB-1 vaccination resulted in a coordinated induction of IL-12p40 and downregulation of suppressors of cytokine signaling 1 and 3, indicative of classical macrophage 1 and T-helper 1 patterning.

Análisis transcripcionales de patrones inmunes innatos y adquiridos inducidos por cepas vacunales del virus de la enfermedad de Marek: virus herpes del pavo (HVT), virus de Marek 2 (cepa SB1) y vacunas bivalentes (HVT/SB1 y HVT-LT/SB1). La enfermedad de Marek (MD) es una patología compleja de los pollos causada por el virus de Marek (MDV) 1 y se observa como parálisis, depresión inmune, signos neurológicos y la formación rápida de linfomas de células T. La incidencia de la enfermedad de Marek en pollos de engorde comerciales se controla en gran medida a través de la vacunación, ya sea in ovo o al momento de la eclosión con vacunas vivas atenuadas, por ejemplo, herpesvirus de pavo (HVT) o una combinación bivalente de HVT con la cepa SB1. Para ampliar aún más la protección conferida por la vacuna bivalente HVT/SB-1, los HVT recombinantes que codifican transgenes de otros virus aviares se han utilizado de forma similar para la administración in ovo. A pesar de décadas de uso, los mecanismos específicos asociados con la protección inducida por la vacuna siguen sin ser esclarecidos completamente. Además, el mecanismo para la sinergia de la vacuna conferida por la vacuna bivalente HVT/SB-1, en comparación con la administración de la cepa HVT o de la cepa SB-1 por sí solas, es en gran medida desconocida. En el presente estudio, se informa sobre los cambios temporales en la expresión genética de patrones inmunes innatos y adquiridos mediante la infección de esplenocitos ex vivo y en modelos de vacunación in ovo. Se reporta que en el modelo de infección de esplenocitos ex vivo, por 72 horas después de la infección, las vacunas indujeron IFN y la expresión de genes estimulada por IFN, con menor inducción de citocinas proinflamatorias. Para varios genes (TLR3, IFNc, OASL, Mx1, NOS2A e IL-1ß), los efectos sobre la expresión de genes fueron aditivos para la infección por HVT, SB1 y HVT/SB1. Se Observaron patrones de inducción similares en embriones de pollo y pollos de engorde comerciales vacunados in ovo con HVT/SB-1 o con la combinación bivalente recombinante basada en HVT (HVT-LT/SB-1). Además, la vacunación in ovo con HVT/SB-1 o HVT-LT/SB-1 parecen acelerar la maduración inmune, con patrones de expresión que sugieren una migración acelerada de células T y células asesinas naturales en el bazo. Finalmente, la vacuna HVT/SB-1 dio como resultado una inducción coordinada de IL-12p40 y una regulación a la baja de supresores de las señales de citocinas 1 y 3, indicativas de los patrones clásicos de macrófagos 1 y células cooperadoras tipo 1.

History of the First-Generation Marek's Disease Vaccines: The Science and Little-Known Facts.

Shortly after the isolation of Marek's disease (MD) herpesvirus (MDV) in the late 1960s vaccines were developed in England, the United States, and The Netherlands. Biggs and associates at the Houghton Poultry Research Station (HPRS) in England attenuated HPRS-16, the first cell-culture-isolated MDV strain, by passaging HPRS-16 in chick kidney cells. Although HPRS-16/Att was the first commercially available vaccine, it never became widely used and was soon replaced by the FC126 strain of herpesvirus of turkeys (HVT) vaccine developed by Witter and associates at the Regional Poultry Research Laboratory (now Avian Disease and Oncology Laboratory [ADOL]) in East Lansing, MI. Ironically, Kawamura et al. isolated a herpesvirus from kidney cell cultures from turkeys in 1969 but never realized its potential as a vaccine against MD. Rispens of the Central Veterinary Institute (CVI) developed the third vaccine. His associate, Maas, had found commercial flocks of chickens with MDV antibodies but without MD. Subsequently, Rispens isolated a very low pathogenic strain from hen number 988 from his MD antibody-positive flock, which was free of avian leukosis virus and clinical MD. This isolate became the CVI-988 vaccine used mostly in The Netherlands. During the late 1970s, HVT was no longer fully protective against some new emerging field strains. The addition of SB-1, isolated by Schat and Calnek, to HVT improved protection against the emerging very virulent strains. In the 1990s CVI-988 became the worldwide vaccine gold standard. This review will present data from published papers and personal communications providing additional information about the exciting 15-yr period after the isolation of MDV to the development of the different vaccines.

Further observations on serotype 2 Marek's disease virus-induced enhancement of spontaneous avian leukosis virus-like bursal lymphomas in ALVA6 transgenic chickens.

Breeders of the 2009 generation of Avian Disease and Oncology Laboratory transgenic chicken line ALVA6, known to be resistant to infection with subgroups A and E avian leukosis virus (ALV), were vaccinated at hatch with a trivalent Marek's disease (MD) vaccine containing serotypes 1, 2, and 3 Marek's disease virus (MDV) and were maintained under pathogen-free conditions from the day of hatch until 75 weeks of age. Spontaneous ALV-like bursal lymphomas, also termed lymphoid leukosis (LL)-like lymphomas, were detected in 7% of the ALVA6 breeders. There was no evidence of infection with exogenous and endogenous ALV as determined by virus isolation tests of plasma and tumour tissue homogenates. For the next three generations, serotype 2 MDV was eliminated from the trivalent MD vaccine used. Results show, for the first time, that removal of serotype 2 MDV from MD vaccines eliminated spontaneous LL-like lymphomas within 50 to 72 weeks of age for at least three consecutive generations. Two experiments were also conducted to determine the influence of in ovo vaccination with serotype 2 MD vaccines on enhancement of spontaneous LL-like lymphomas in ALVA6 chickens. Chickens from the 2012 generation were each inoculated in ovo or at hatch with 5000 plaque-forming units of serotype 2 MDV. Results indicate that by 50 weeks of age the incidence of spontaneous LL-like lymphomas in chickens inoculated in ovo with serotype 2 MDV was comparable with that in chickens inoculated with virus at hatch, suggesting that the augmentation effect of serotype 2 MDV is independent of age of vaccination.

Detection and differentiation of CVI988 (Rispens vaccine) from other serotype 1 Marek's disease viruses.

The serotype 1 Marek's disease virus (MDV) is the causative agent for Marek's disease (MD), a lymphoproliferative disease of chickens of great concern to the poultry industry. CVI988 (Rispens vaccine), an attenuated serotype 1 MDV, is currently the most efficacious commercially available vaccine for preventing MD. However, it is difficult to detect and differentiate CVI988 when other serotype 1 MDVs are present. To facilitate the detection of CVI988, we developed two sets of primers for a mismatch amplification mutation assay (MAMA) PCR that targeted the single nulceotide polymorphism associated with the H19 epitope of the phosphorylated protein 38 gene. The PCR was very specific. One primer set (oncogenic primers) amplified DNA from 15 different serotype 1 MDVs except CVI988. The other primer set (CVI988 primers) amplified DNA from CVI988 but not from any of the other 15 serotype 1 MDVs. A real-time PCR assay was developed using MAMA primers, and specificity and sensitivity was evaluated in vitro and in vivo. Mixtures of plasmids (CVI988 plasmid and oncogenic plasmid) at various concentrations were used to evaluate the sensitivity/specificity of MAMA primers in vitro. Both primer setswere able to amplify as little as one copy of their respective plasmid. Oncogenic primers were highly specific and only amplified CVI988 plasmid when the concentration of oncogenic plasmid was very low (1 X 10(1)) and CVI988 plasmid was very high (1 X 10(6)). Specificity of CVI988 primers was not as high because they could amplify oncogenic plasmids when the concentration of CVI988 plasmid was 1 x 10(3) and the concentration of oncogenic 1 x 10(2). Validation of MAMA primers in in vivo samples demonstrated that oncogenic primers can be used for both early diagnosis of MD in feather pulp (FP) samples collected at 3 wk of age and confirmation of MD diagnosis in tumors. CVI988 primers could be used to monitor CVI988 vaccination in samples with a low load of oncogenic MDV DNA (latently infected samples or negative) but not in samples with a high load of oncogenic MDV DNA (tumors). Our results suggest that monitoring CVI988 vaccination in FP samples collected at 1 wk of age ensures the specificity of the CVI988 primers.

Characterization of cytotoxicity-related gene expression in response to virulent Marek's disease virus infection in the bursa of Fabricius.

Cell-mediated cytotoxic responses are critical for control of Marek's disease virus (MDV) infection and tumour development. However, the mechanisms of virus clearance mediated by cytotoxic responses in the bursa of Fabricius of chickens during MDV infection are not fully understood. In this study, the host cytotoxic responses during MDV infection in the bursa were investigated by examining the expression of genes in the cell lysis pathways. Partial up-regulation existed in the expression of the important cytolytic molecule granzyme A (GzmA), Fas, NK lysin and DNA repair enzyme Ape1, whereas little or no expression appeared in other cytolytic molecules, including perforin (PFN) and Fas ligand (FasL), and molecules involved in DNA repair and apoptosis in the bursa during MDV infection. These results suggest that less sustained cytotoxic activities are generated in the bursa of MDV-infected chickens. The findings of this study provide a more detailed insight into the host cytotoxic responses to MDV infection.

A toll-like receptor 3 ligand enhances protective effects of vaccination against Marek's disease virus and hinders tumor development in chickens.

Marek's disease (MD) is caused by Marek's disease virus (MDV). Various vaccines including herpesvirus of turkeys (HVT) have been used to control this disease. However, HVT is not able to completely protect against very virulent strains of MDV. The objective of this study was to determine whether a vaccination protocol consisting of HVT and a Toll-like receptor (TLR) ligand could enhance protective efficacy of vaccination against MD. Hence, chickens were immunized with HVT and subsequently treated with synthetic double-stranded RNA polyriboinosinic polyribocytidylic [poly(I:C)], a TLR3 ligand, before or after being infected with a very virulent strain of MDV. Among the groups that were HVT-vaccinated and challenged with MDV, the lowest incidence of tumors was observed in the group that received poly(I:C) before and after MDV infection. Moreover, the groups that received a single poly(I:C) treatment either before or after MDV infection were better protected against MD tumors compared to the group that only received HVT. No association was observed between viral load, as determined by MDV genome copy number, and the reduction in tumor formation. Overall, the results presented here indicate that poly(I:C) treatment, especially when it is administered prior to and after HVT vaccination, enhances the efficacy of HVT vaccine and improves protection against MDV.

Antibody response of chickens to serotype 1, 2, or 3 Marek's disease vaccines based on ELISA with infected cells as antigen.

An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was applied to evaluate the antibody response of commercial White Leghorn chickens to vaccination against Marek's disease (MD) at hatch (day 0) with serotype-1 (Rispens), -2 (SB-1), or -3 (turkey herpesvirus, HVT) vaccine virus and to challenge on day 21 with MD virus. Antigens for the test were whole chicken embryo fibroblast cells infected with Rispens, SB-1, or HVT. The chickens were progeny of stock that had been vaccinated with HVT, and on day 21 the nonvaccinated group had higher levels of maternal antibodies to HVT than to other antigens (P < 0.05). Only SB-1 vaccine had induced antibodies by day 21, and this was detected only against homologous antigens. On day 49, all three vaccines had induced higher levels of antibodies to homologous than to heterologous antigens. Marek's Disease virus (MDV) induced antibodies to all three antigens, but challenging vaccinated chicks did not significantly increase levels of antibodies on day 81 to any of the three antigens. It was concluded that an ELISA using whole cells as antigens would have potential value for monitoring the antibody response induced by MD vaccines and virulent MDV.

Absolute quantification using real-time polymerase chain reaction of Marek's disease virus serotype 2 in field dust samples, feather tips and spleens.

Methods for Taqman quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) assays to detect the three serotypes of Marek's disease virus (MDV) are available, and absolute quantification has been developed for MDV serotype 1 and serotype 3. The development of a method for absolute quantification of Marek's disease virus serotype 2 (MDV2) is described in this paper. Using plasmid DNA, the lower detection limit of the MDV2 assay was determined to be 10 copies. Three independent assay runs showed highly reproducible Ct values and calculated copy numbers, with mean intra- and inter-assay coefficients of variation of less than 3% for Ct and less than 21.5% for calculated copy number. Absolute quantification of MDV2 was performed successfully on dust samples collected from poultry farms across Australia, material from infectious spleens and feather tips from chickens vaccinated with an attenuated strain of MDV2. Thus, it is now possible to use qPCR assays for absolute quantification of all three serotypes of MDV in a sample.

The efficacy of recombinant fowlpox vaccine protection against Marek's disease: its dependence on chicken line and B haplotype.

Earlier studies have shown that the B haplotype has a significant influence on the protective efficacy of vaccines against Marek's disease (MD) and that the level of protection varies dependent on the serotype of MD virus (MDV) used in the vaccine. To determine if the protective glycoprotein gene gB is a basis for this association, we compared recombinant fowlpox virus (rFPV) containing a single gB gene from three serotypes of MDV. The rFPV were used to vaccinate 15.B congenic lines. Nonvaccinated chickens from all three haplotypes had 84%-97% MD after challenge. The rFPV containing gB1 provides better protection than rFPV containing gB2 or gB3 in all three B genotypes. Moreover, the gB proteins were critical, since the B*21/*21 chickens had better protection than chickens with B*13/*13 or B*5/*5 using rFPV with gB1, gB2, or gB3. A newly described combined rFPV/gB1gEgIUL32 + HVT vaccine was analyzed in chickens of lines 15 x 7 (B*2/*15) and N (B*21/*21) challenged with two vv+ strains of MDV. There were line differences in protection by the vaccines and line N had better protection with the rFPV/gB1gEgIUL32 + HVT vaccines (92%-100%) following either MDV challenge, but protection was significantly lower in 15 X 7 chickens (35%) when compared with the vaccine CVI988/Rispens (94%) and 301B1 + HVT (65%). Another experiment used four lines of chickens receiving the new rFPV + HVT vaccine or CVI988/Rispens and challenge with 648A MDV. The CVI 988/Rispens generally provided better protection in lines P and 15 X 7 and in one replicate with line TK. The combined rFPV/gB1gEgIUL32 + HVT vaccines protected line N chickens (90%) better than did CVI988/Rispens (73%). These data indicate that rFPV + HVT vaccines may provide protection against MD that is equivalent to or superior to CVI988/ Rispens in some chicken strains. It is not clear whether the rFPV/gB1gEgIUL32 + HVT vaccine will offer high levels of protection to commercial strains, but this vaccine, when used in line N chickens, may be a useful model to study interactions between vaccines and chicken genotypes and may thereby improve future MD vaccines.